In the cave...

[twobeaglegirl]

No: HPFGUIDX 138098


I'm sorry if this theory has been explored before, but has anyone 
considered the possibility that the horcrux in the cave could have 
possibly been the liquid in which the locket was immersed, and not 
the locket itself?

It might explain why drinking it caused DD so much anguish, and it 
could also tie into the necessity of "notESE!Snape" having to AK 
him, so that the horcrux (now inside DD) would be destroyed.

Just a thought.

--2 beagles