[HPforGrownups] Faked death or faked AK? (Was: The Truth about the 6th Harry Potter Book)

[Scarah]

No: HPFGUIDX 138127

> Sherry now:
> 

> Again, as I have asked before among others who have asked the same thing, if
> this was a plan between Dumbledore and Snape, why oh why didn't they tell
> Harry in advance?  That was poor planning in the extreme, and I'd have
> thought both men were more intelligent than that to leave such an important
> detail out of things.  With the history of hatred between Snape and Harry,
> it was ridiculous to plot this thing and then leave Harry to believe what he
> believes.  

Sarah:
Why would they want Harry to know the truth?  That is  the best part
of the whole plan.  Harry never learned Occlumency, LV can look into
his head any time he wants.  Now when he does, he won't see anything
but his best uberminion being superloyal.

Having Harry witness it and believe what he believes is the best thing
that could have happened.

Sarah