In defence of (Uncharacteristic) Dumbledore

[ehteshamulh]

No: HPFGUIDX 138156

If it is true that Dumbledore feels his time coming to an end, then 
his interview with the Dursleys is a final interaction for 
summarizing the reason that Harry was fostered with them and a 
request to let Harry return once more to Privet Drive. Knowing how 
strongly Dumbledore feels about Harry, and how he has been treated 
by the Dursleys all these years, I think Dumbledore is excercising 
remarkable restraint. Also remember, no doubt Dumbledore feels guilt 
for all the abuse Harry suffered through while growing up, because 
it was Dumbledore himself who made that choice about Harry's 
upbringing.

And what's all this about him being disarmed? Dumbledore has 
consistently shown how important he thinks Harry is, both as an 
individual and as regards the grand scheme of things (his reaction 
when LV possesses Harry, the "your blood is more valuable" comment 
in the cave). He is making a choice here, giving up a potential 
chance at self-defence to keep Harry immobilized and safe (at least 
to Dumbledore's mind).

And as a final thought about being polite to the extreme, the 
conversation that Dumbledore has with the Death Eaters on the Tower 
was amazing: here was Dumbledore at his most defenseless, and still 
showing impeccable poise: "Jokes? No, no, these are manners." To 
paraphrase another Master for the light: "When one hundred and fifty 
years old, wandless, and surrounded by enemies you are, be as full 
of grace you will not."

Hmm?

Ehtesham