Secret Keepers (was: Several replies and answers)

Fabian Peng Krrholm fabian.peng-karrholm at chalmers.se
Sat Aug 20 08:20:54 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 138187

Valky:
>Dumbledore is not hiding himself in Grimmauld place, he hides the 
>Headquarters of the OOtP. He is the leader of the OOtP, a
>separate entity from the Headquarters. James Lily and Harry were the
>entities being hidden by the SK charm. If it was written down in a
>note the note would say "James, Lily and Harry Potter are at - ##
>abcdefg street Godrics Hollow" and I think that while you are the
>secret you cannot be the secret keeper. Making it reasonably
>consistent in its inner workings. 


Fabian:
Ok, let me rephrase myself then. I think the smarter course of action 
would be to have the note say "The home of James, Lily and Harry Potter are at .....". And then themselves could be the secretkeeper. Of course, it's not really relevant, since as someone pointed out, there'd be no books to read if they did.

/Fabian








More information about the HPforGrownups archive