YES ( was: Did Snape "murder" Dumbledore?)

[Fabian Peng Krrholm]

No: HPFGUIDX 138246

>Alla:
>
>Umm, I thought that Snape was very nasty to Harry during all five 
>years, but that is just me.
>
>  
>
<snip>

Having re-read the first four books and halfway through the fifth; I 
have to say that (I think Snape is on DD side), considering that he's 
supposed to be undercover, what he's doing is not as bad as it might 
seem. He has singled out HP of course, but many times he gives him 
detention or so for a reason, vague reasons sometimes, but still. It 
just becomes clear in the fifth book especially, when he's compared to 
Umbridge, who's just evil beyond repair.
 One thing I think is out of the picture of a Snape on DD side, is that 
he is not that interested in Harry becoming an Auror or not. As for 
example McGonagall. But that could just be a minor thing.

Wouldn't it be fun to read the Diaries of Snape after the 7th book is 
released? Of course keeping a diary might not be very Snapeish, but still.

/Fabian