Witherwings /was Spinners End and Dumbledore

[kiricat4001]

No: HPFGUIDX 138284

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tonks" <tonks_op at y...> wrote:

> Also we have Bucky renamed in hiding. We have an offer to do the 
same 
> for the Mayfoys. There seems to be a theme here, but just how far 
does 
> it goes? And why does she bring it up at all?  I think that DD is 
> really dead, so I am not going there for him, except that he might 
come 
> back later as a phoenix.  But why would she bring up the idea of 
> renaming and hiding (maybe in plain sight) and then not use it for 
> something more important?

Marianne:

Perhaps Herself is setting up something to be revealed in Book 7, 
much as she has mentioned things or people in one book and suddenly, 
they appear in a later book.  I agree, this seems like something 
that was mentioned too often to simply leave it at that.  I am not 
at all a fan of the idea that DD's death was faked, so I don't think 
JKR will do a bait and switch of his "corpse."  At least, I hope 
not.  However, I wouldn't be surprised to come across a character in 
Book 7 who has been hidden in the past in some way. 

And how did DD plan to hide the Malfoys? In a secret location with 
himself as Secret Keeper? 

Marianne