DD definitely dead

[ellecain]

No: HPFGUIDX 138301

>Ceridwen:
>I still cling to *my* baby, that Dumbledore was already dead, and is
>only temporarily alive due to Harry's double 'rennervate' and his
>plea. Second favorite possibility, that he was dying already,
>noticeable evidence in the Tower chapter, and the time had passed
>where intervention would be possible. But, I like your Slughorn
>theory, too. Maybe our two babies could play together for a while,
>at least until book 7 comes out?



Sorry to shoot your babies down, 
but doesnt DD say in GoF that
"no spell can reawaken the dead".
This ought to put an end to all the
DD-was-already-dead-and-came-back-to-life speculation.... 

Try going after the faked death scenario instead.

Elyse
(who believes that DD is well and truly gone)