[HPforGrownups] DD definitely dead

[Bee Chase]

No: HPFGUIDX 138328


> Elyse wrote
> 
> Sorry to shoot your babies down,
> but doesnt DD say in GoF that
> "no spell can reawaken the dead".
> This ought to put an end to all the
> DD-was-already-dead-and-came-back-to-life speculation....
> 
> Try going after the faked death scenario instead.
> 
> Elyse
> (who believes that DD is well and truly gone)


Tanya.

While I am not convinced that DD is it.  I would like to see someone
from the 'good' side faking a death to even things up so to speak.  We
already have Peter and Crouch jnr.

Luckdragon:

I am having great difficulty in believing this death. DD was just too smart to go like that. If anyone could prevent his death from the potion it was Snape, who if I recall correctly told his first year potion students that "he could teach them to put a Stopper on death". He actually saved DD from the effects of the potion while making it look like he killed him. This was all pre-arranged and DD is in hiding, recuperating from his near death experience. BTW:I believe the Phoenix Harry saw arise from the flames at DD's funeral was actually his patronus being sent with a message for Snape or a member of the order who will appear in the next book.








		
---------------------------------
Find your next car at Yahoo! Canada Autos

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]