It's over, Snape is evil (but maybe not 100%)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138365

juli17 at a... wrote:


> Some of the things you've written seem
> to imply if JKR doesn't write what 
> *you* want-- Snape ESE, Dumbledore 
> irrefutably dead--then she will be
> betraying her genius.

If Dumbledore comes back from the dead then JKR has missed the ball no
doubt about it, she's still a genius but she missed the ball. And I
wish people would stop with this "ESE" nonsense; Snape is evil, Snape
is a villain, but Snape is not Doctor Doom or Lex Luther; Snape is
more complex than that and would not feel comfortable in a comic book.
    

> JKR has no *duty* whatsoever in regards to
> her writing, other than to suit herself.

I could not agree with you more. If a genius of JKR's caliber is happy
with the next book I don't have the slightest doubt I will be happy
with it too.

Eggplant