Slughorn and Dumbledore: possible motive

[Virginia Villamediana]

No: HPFGUIDX 138465

> > hg:
> > The idea that Dumbledore's death 
> > was faked hasn't been warmly received on any board, so I've 
been "in the closet" on this one.  But I've been collecting evidence 
and re-reading carefully; I've got a lot of indicators that it 
happened, but without being able to secure a motive, I've been 
reluctant to post.

 
Auria:
> You said 
> you can't secure a motive.  Well let me try here.  Dumbledore knows 
> that LV can link into Harry's thoughts just as Harry could link to 
LV's before LV started operating occlumency against Harry.  So 
logically Dumbledore would not want Harry to know of any plot to 
outsmart LV and defeat him in case LV can practise legilimens on 
Harry and find out.  


Virginia now:
hg, I really like your theory and I really would like it to be 
true. I also would like to see your complete list of inconsistencies, 
but I have a question. 

If Dumbledore doesn't want Voldemort to read in Harry’s mind that 
Dumbledore is not really death, I suppose they wouldn't want either 
that Voldemort reads that they know about the horcruxes. So why they 
would let Harry to know about the horcruxes and not about the fake 
death plan if they are afraid of Voldemort reading Harry’s mind?

Virginia.