HARRY'S SCAR IS NOT A HORCRUX

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 138511

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "lebowjessica" 
<lebowjessica at y...> wrote:
> I don't believe   that Harry's scar is a Horcrux, as many
> believe or a remnant of the backfired AK curse.  I think as we 
will  find out in Book 7 that Lily Potter was far more clever than 
has been  revealed until now , we hear glimpses and bits and pieces 
of her expertise in charms and potions, and I believe through her 
knowledge of charms is what created Harry's scar and continues to 
guide and protect him.



doddie here:

I disagree and agree....what if Lilly charmed the last of GG's last 
remaining heirlooms....

What if Voldemort went to GG's hollow to create his last horcrux....

How fitting that snape did all the spells necessary to create a 
horcrux yet the only thing lilly didn't charm but protect was 
harry???

>  
> JKR has said that this type of sacrifice was never made in the WW 

doddie here:

well I don't know that she said that...seldom perhaps.

doddie gone..

> LV and DD said that Lily used a powerful and ancient magic that LV 
> did not know of or had forgotten, this is also why I think it is 
> significant of the color of Harry's eyes the green also
> represents a very powerful "ancient" magic ruled by charms. 


Doddie here:  I'm thinking that the potions book in HBP may reveal 
something about horcruxes....and Lily may have seen it..

doddie gone...

Harry has chose and accepted for quite some time now...so I do not 
disagree with your postulations...you just have to make your 
assumptions more meticulous throughout the series...(don't know if 
you can or not)....tee hee canor not...cannon or not...

Doddie,

(who wonders if Lily pretended to be close to snape to understand 
him better)