Harry as a Horcrux
Geoff Bannister
gbannister10 at tiscali.co.uk
Thu Aug 25 10:22:28 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 138696
Geoff:
Let me first of all say that I haven't been following the threads on
Horcruxes since 16/07 in any great detail - they're in the same
category to me as Snape in that, being a bear of very little brain, I
haven't tried to think my way through the maze of conflicting and
speculative theorising that has enveloped the group about these topics.
However, I was casually skimming through one or two posts when the
following thought occurred to me. I think it has been postulated that
if the "vessel" holding the Horcrux is destroyed, then the Horcrux
itself is destroyed.
Right. Now, if Harry is a a Horcrux - or carrying a Horcrux - depending
on your view, why has Voldemort attempted to kill Harry on several
oocasions which would not do the Horcrux a lot of good?
I shall now sit back and wait for messages asking why I haven't been
paying attention at the back of the class because this has been
answered at least 49 times in the last five weeks. :-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive