Snape did kill DD with AK!! And here's the evidenc

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138729

juli17 at a... wrote:

> I would respectfully ask that you
> quit demeaning people 

I haven't demeaned anybody, but I do say that the idea Snape made an
Unbreakable Vow because a pretty woman batted her eyelashes at him, or
on a whim, or he didn't know what he was vowing to do, or that he just
didn't think it through, is, well
.. silly. There is just no other
word for it.

> let us all concede that we do not 
> KNOW what will happen, we can only guess

Yes, I would concede that.

> any guess is as valid as another

That I will not concede. For example, If JKR wanted  she could end the
series with Harry being an 11 year old Muggle waking up in a closet
under the Dursley's staircase and all 7 books turn out to be one big
dream. If she did that it would contradict nothing but it would still
be a poor prediction of what will happen in the next book. Having
Snape be a good guy and Dumbledore alive and well is not quite as bad
as that but almost.  

Eggplant