The Eggplant and Snape and I

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138872

CathyD Wrote:

> he [Snape] got at least 25% of his
> 40 fifth-year students to achieve 
> an Outstanding OWL.  

In previous years Snape must have been teaching an entire other
potions class that we have never seen for Ravenclaws and Hufflepuffs,
and we don't know exactly how many students were in either class.
Also, it's a rather long chain of reasoning to go from Harry and Ron
were the only ones we see ask for a potions book to all the others
must have gotten Outstanding. And we don't really know how rare an
Outstanding is in potions, although I will concede it must be rare in
Defense Against The Dark Arts if even Hermione can't get an O;
although in that case Harry may have blown the curve. 

Eggplant