Wasn't Anyone Else Disappointed?

tamuril elensar reyakittens at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 30 14:04:16 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 139118

Richard Jones wrote:
> The middle of the book was well, dull compared to the other 
> books.  Of course, things picked up at the end, but all I can say is 
> that a thought forced itself into my mind while reading the middle of 
> HBP that never ever occurred to me while reading any of the other 
> five books — "when will this be over?" 


I actually loved this book but I did feel that way with Book 5 during
re-reads.  I think that that is why I loved 6 so much.  Book 5 I felt
was too long and too miserable.  Nothing seemed to go right except for
the DA lessons.  I found myself getting as frustrated as the
characters.. and I don't know.. you never want to feel frustrating
when reading!

Robyn









More information about the HPforGrownups archive