R.A.B.'s identity confirmed?

[Merry Kinsella]

No: HPFGUIDX 139169

carodave wrote:
- maybe 
in the end Regulus did something to save / help Sirius as part of his redemption?  Maybe Sirius had something to do with his brother's decision to leave the DEs?<<


Merylanna:

I'm going further and wondering if Regulus ever sincerely joined the death eaters.  Perhaps in his own way he loathed them as much as Sirius did, only went about it differently - to learn about and undermine them from within.  Then he staged (or embraced, if he did die taking that horcrux) his death.

Sirius may be wrong about Snape, he may be mistaken about Regulus - he may never have re-framed his conclusions about people once he formed them at a very young age.  He is very convinced about his family and he, himself, being the only black (good) sheep - his brother may have been undercover and Sirius not suspected.




		
---------------------------------
 Start your day with Yahoo! - make it your home page 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]