Is Snape the only character who can teach lessons WAS: Snape, Hagrid and animals
hpfan_mom
rdsilverstein at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 2 20:20:01 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 143929
va_32h writes:
<snip>There is a world of other characters who already embody the lessons that Snape's redemption could teach.
>
>Gerry replies:
> But Snape is the only one who was actually a Death Eater. If he is
> evil, it is an easy conclusion that it's once a Death Eater, allways a
> Death Eater. Once evil, always evil. The others were on the side of
> good in the first place.
hpfan_mom:
We also have Regulus as a Death Eater who attempted to recant. If he
turns up in Book 7, he could also be a vehicle for a lesson on
redemption. Of course, he might be too busy explaining how he
destroyed the locket horcrux. ;)
hpfan_mom
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive