The Significance of the Foe-Glass

[truthbeauty1]

No: HPFGUIDX 144021

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "leslie41" <leslie41 at y...> wrote:

> Well, for one thing, it seems to me to be incontrovertable proof 
> that, at least as of the end of GoF, Snape was on the side of good, 
> or at least opposed to Barty Crouch Jr.

 
> I haven't yet heard of any reasonable explanation of this which 
> could show anything otherwise, though I'm open to persuasion.
> 
> And of course if Snape is with the forces of good at the end of GoF, 
> he goes back to Voldemort as a double-agent for DUMBLEDORE, not for 
> the Dark Lord.
> 
> Leslie

   I am not decided about Snape, however, if you look for both good
Snape and bad Snape from this scene you can. If Snape is still a true
Death Eater, then one could simply say that all Death Eaters who
renounced Voldemort for whatever reason are Crouches enemies. When he
is talking to Harry after the graveyard scene, he does seem quite
militant about those who returned to Voldemort. I personally do not
believe that Rowling will give anything away about Snape until the
very moment that truth becomes paramount.
 truthbeauty1