The Significance of the Foe-Glass

[rosered2318]

No: HPFGUIDX 144036

Christina:


I believe that the foe-glass issue would be
> particularly difficult to explain away (and was a completely
> unnecessary addition to the book).


Rosered:
You made my point better than I could by saying the opposite of what I 
think.  Snape is not seen looking into the foe-glass in the movie, and 
yet the foe-glass is still in the movie.  Then it shows up again twice 
in book 5.  If it was completely unnecessary, why have we been 
reminded of it and why was it kept in the movie?  I find it very 
suspect.  

Rosered.