There are no new theories! / Pettigrew / DDM!Snape

[mjanetd]

No: HPFGUIDX 144326

Allison aka "allies426" wrote:
> The longer I read this list, the more convinced I am that there 
> are NO NEW theories about Harry Potter!  (e.g., "I think Snape
> was in love with Lily!"  "Has anyone considered that Harry is a 
> Horcrux?"  "Has anyone noticed the locket that they find at 
> Grimmauld place?")  I'm not making fun, it's just funny the way 
> it happens and every once in a while someone really does say 
> something new.


I'm new but I've been reading some of the older post and haven't 
seen anyone mention my little theory so forgive me if it's been 
discussed to death. :)  I think Peter betrayed James and Lily 
because he wanted Lily for himself.  I don't remember in which 
book so I can't an exact quote but I remember that when LV was 
trying to kill Harry he told Lily to move out of the way at 
least twice.  He had already killed James so why didn't he 
quickly kill Lily too?  

I see from recent messages and old ones that Snape gets a lot of
discussion time.  I've always liked Snape but couldn't tell you 
why. Maybe it's because I really like the actor that plays him.  
I saw PS/SS and COS before buying my first HP book and that's 
colored my view of all the characters.     

I'm still hopeful that Snape is working for Dumbledore.  I 
expected to find out at the end of the HBP that Dumbledore was 
still alive and that Snape and Dumbledore had worked out a plan 
to convince LV that his 2nd biggest threat was gone. 

Sadly that didn't happen but I still think that Snape didn't 
know about LV's plan when the evil twits came to his house.  He 
said he knew but he never gave any information about the plan 
only vague comments that could be taken in whatever way the 
listener wanted. 

I really like the idea of someone so... unlikeable is on the 
side of Good.  Maybe I'm reading the wrong kind of books but 
it's usually very easy to spot the good from the bad guys.  

"mjanetd"