Enchanted Items
Bart Lidofsky
bartl at sprynet.com
Thu Dec 8 15:39:31 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 144336
Here's a mystery in the HP books that I don't think has been covered.
There are a number of items with magic powers which are mentioned. It is
implied that they are rare; at the very least, difficult to replace.
Yet, they are not treated as if they were rare and valuable. Also, there
don't seem to be any classes in artificing, except, perhaps, Potions.
Fred and George seem to have picked up the skills on their own, yet the
skills seem to be in demand. It is very strange.
Let me give a few examples:
1) Harry's Invisibility Cloak: Aurors have trouble getting one (from
OOP), a lot of people know that Harry has one, they're pretty easy to
hide. Harry kept his pretty much a secret from all but Dumbledore (who,
we ASSUME, passed it on to him; certainly he showed no concern that
Harry had it). Yet, nobody tries to steal it from him, not even Draco
Malfoy when he has the opportunity.
2) The Weasley clock. From Dumbledore's comments in OOP, it's not
something that every family has. Why not? Especially considering that
the Weasleys are poor; I assume that the clock customizes itself for the
family (unless they didn't obtain it until after Ginny was born).
3) Squibs. Considering how little most magical families supposedly know
about Muggles, squibs would have a great deal of difficulty getting by
in the Muggle world. One would think that someone could make decent
money, especially if the Ministry kicks in, making magical
prothetics/aids/etc. Why is this not happening?
Any theories?
Bart
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive