DD's Penseive

h2so3f h2so3f at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 9 02:41:54 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144383

Debbie R  wrote:
"I haven't posted since July and am WAY behind on my post-reading, 
so my apologies if this particular "what if" has been covered 
already......
Do you suppose that DD could have left some memories in his pensieve 
that might shed some light on things for Harry (and Minerva since 
she would be the one to find them)....or was it left obviously empty 
(I can't remember if it was mentioned in the final scene of the 
office & my book is currently inaccessible) ??? "


CH3ed:
Hi Debbie R! The question was discussed here about 1 to 1 1/2 weeks 
ago. I think the general understanding is that the penseive is not 
where one would store memories long term. DD showed Harry memories 
he kept in vials and not one already in the pensieve... except for 
when Harry interupted a discussion between DD (who was using the 
pensieve and who then put it away hurriedly when alerted of Harry's 
presence) and Fudge and Fake Moody in GoF. So it is unlikely that 
there is any memory in DD's pensieve. There may be memories in vials 
at the Headmaster's office, tho.

CH3ed  :O)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive