Dumbledore may not be dead after all!

Hrishikesh bawa_hrishikesh at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 9 10:27:17 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144414

We all know that Rowling is exceptionally good at putting 
various twists and turns into the saga. There are quite many 
clues in HBP that indicate so! 

First of all we must all acknowledge that both Dumbledore & 
Snape are great Legilimens & Occlumens. So when Dumbledore 
says "please.." to Snape during the end of the book, Albus 
might have told Snape to do something else!

The way in which the killing curse was performed was also speculating, as normally the victim just seems to limp off 
dead, but Dumbledore was blasted away. Besides, in OOP, 
Bellatrix says that to perform the Unforgivable curses, one 
must actually mean them (Snape might not have meant to kill), 
and we all know that Snape is very good at Non-Verbal Spells, 
so he must used some other incantaion! And Dumbledore might 
have used a Non-Verbal Spell to free Harry of the Body Bind!

Also during Aragog's funeral, in one song it is mentioned that, 
the dead wizard's wand was snapped, Dumbledore's wand was not 
found! 

During his funeral we do not get to see his body, only a 
package, which might be containing anything else too. 

Also once during his lessons Dumbledore extracts his memory 
from a bottle instead of his dead! The real one would easily 
remove it from his head, only one who is not Dumbledore may 
need to use the bottle!

Besides Dumbledore is always associated with a Phoenix so he 
might as well rise from his ashes!

And let's all be as optimistic as Luna who says once that 
although her mother kicked the bucket in a freak experiment, 
she expects her to return due to the veil in the Department 
of Mysteries! Let's Hope godd all Dumbledore makes a Come-Back, 
& that Snape is not a Traitor after all.

"Hrishikesh"







More information about the HPforGrownups archive