Snape may not be a Traitor

Hrishikesh bawa_hrishikesh at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 9 10:38:09 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144415

There are many clues which indicate that Snape may not be a 
traitor to our side! 

We first start at Spinner's End. We know that Snape is a great 
Legilimens. When Narcissa was in an Emotional turmoil Snape 
glanced at her and then frowned! As I see it, Snape got 
information on what the task was that Draco had to perform by 
using Leglimens easily as Cissy was weak minded then, he used 
this information to gain their trust, might have informed 
Dumbledore all about the plans.

We must also acknowledge that Snape is extremely good at 
Non-Verbval Spells, and when he killed Dumbledore, he might 
used some other spell. Besides, the way in which Dumbledore's 
killed is quite speculating, as normally after the use of Avada Kedavara, the victim just simply limps off to death, but 
Dumbledore was blasted off! 

Also when dumbledore says "Severus Please..." in the same 
chapter, both of them being accomplished Legilimens & Occlumens, 
may have conveyed some plan via their brains hitherto unknown to 
others. 

Hence I believe that Snape may be on our side after all. There 
are some clues that indicate some speculations in Dumbledore's 
death for which please view my article, "Dumbledore may not be 
dead after all".

-Santulan











More information about the HPforGrownups archive