Cultural standards for Snape abusiveness/Karma again/Mcgonagall and Neville

[amiabledorsai]

No: HPFGUIDX 144458

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ornadv" <ornawn at 0...> wrote:
>
> >Pippin:
> >I guess I am not clear what Snape is supposed to be punished for,
> >DDM!Snape, I mean. If it is for serving Voldemort, then I think he 
> >is supposed to have paid for his crimes by changing sides and
> > saving Harry.

Just a quick query: when has Snape saved Harry?  The time Quirrelmort
cursed his broom?  OK, I'll give him good intentions (probably), and
of course he gets credited with an assist, but Hermione is the one who
actually (and accidentally) saved Harry.

The night Lupin went for a moonlight stroll?  Padfoot drove Moony away
from the rest of the party (saving Snape in the process) and Harry
drove away the Dementors (probably saving the unconscious Snape from
being Kissed).  What did Snape do other than take credit?

It's nagging at me that I've probably missed another incident, but
nothing comes to mind.

Amiable Dorsai