How did Bella follow Cissy?
quigonginger
quigonginger at yahoo.com
Sat Dec 10 21:15:30 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 144472
Pippin wrote:
> There doesn't seem to be a way to track a Disapparated person.
(snip)
> Now, according to the Ministry's Apparation instructor, you have
to have your
> destination clearly in mind to Apparate successfully. Bella
> had never been to Spinner's End before and Narcissa acts as though
she
> didn't want Bella along.
>
> How did Bella learn where she was going?
>
> Was Narcissa's thought read against her will before she Apparated?
> Did Cissy "leak" the information because she already intended to
ask
> Snape to take the vow?
Ginger takes a stab at it:
I think we can agree that since Bella taught Draco Occlumancy that
she must have at least rudimentary Legilamancy skills. Cissy was
upset at the time when she apparated into Snape's neighbourhood, and
their conversation indicated to me that they had been arguing about
this very topic before Cissy left.
My guess would be that Bella was using Legilamancy on her, and that
the thoughts passing between them formed a sort of trail or homing
device that Bella was able to follow.
The only time that I can recall that people have apparated to an
unknown destination (not including side-along) was when the DEs went
to the Graveyard, at which time I think the Dark Mark acted in the
same manner as what I am proposing here.
I would assume that there has to be some sort of way that one can
tell someone "follow me" when apparating. Otherwise how could people
know how to get to someone's house if they didn't have a map handy
and weren't familiar with the local geography?
If, for example, Hermione were to invite Ron to visit her parents,
they would have to apparate or take Muggle transportation. Given my
choice, I'd apparate. Cheaper and faster. Since Ron has never seen
her home, nor is he likely familiar with her neighbourhood, she'd
have to have some way of getting him there.
I would guess that the "follow me" idea is a mental path that the
person leading can put out for the other to follow, and in the case
of Bella and Cissy it was not a conscious decision on Cissy's part,
but rather an intrusive one on Bella's, which she accomplished by
Legilamancy.
And that's my jaw-wagging for the day.
All ideas which are not canon are my opinion. Agreement is
acceptable, but is not required. All persons reading are equally
entitled to their own opinions, which may vary. Discontinue use if
rash occurs.
Ginger, with nothing intelligent to put after her name
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive