Snape's karma and a bit of Neville WAS: Re: Cultural standards

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 144481

Alla previously:
> > Fake!Moody was kissed for the abuse he dished in the classroom. 
Check.

Gerry:
> He was? Then what was his punishment for killing his father, for
> putting Harry's name in the Goblet and for making it into a portkey
> that transported Harry and Cedric to the graveyard, which made him 
an
> accomplice to the death of Cedric and the ressurection of LV?


Alla:

Oh, sorry, sorry, sorry. I was so concentrated on the "abuse of 
power" aspect of karmic punishment that I did not make myself clear 
about this example. OF COURSE Fake!Moody was punished for all of 
that too, but if you are going to argue that he was not punished for 
how he treated Neville , I think I will disagree.

IMO and IMO only Fake!Moody was punished for who he was, as a 
package deal , you know.

I think Snape will be punished the same way ( hopefully NOT dementor 
kiss, I would not wish that even on character like Snape) - as a 
package deal for who he is.

La Gatta:
> As someone else pointed out awhile back, Neville may have been 
> choosing to face up to a fear which he could handle in making 
Snape 
> his boggart. <snip> 


Alla:

Do we have a canon to show that person can choose one's fear? For 
example even if Neville was afraid of his gran, it seemed to me that 
Boggart had no problem choosing what his primary fear is. IMO of 
course.


JMO,

Alla