Can Somebody Please Tell Me
amiabledorsai
amiabledorsai at yahoo.com
Sun Dec 11 03:38:11 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 144493
lagattalucianese:
Where does the expression "greasy git" come from? Is it
canon?
Amiable Dorsai:
His hair is greasy, that much is canon. "Git" is a somewhat
overly polite way to refer to him, but it never hurts to be
polite, and the alliteration is nice.
Geoff:
As a UK English speaker, I would consider "git" as anything but
polite. I would consider it extremely unpleasant and if I was on
the receiving end of the name, I think I would want very little
to do with the person who said it.
>
Amiable Dorsai:
I feel certain that "git" would be quite impolite if applied to
*you*.
Betsy Hp:
Can I just add how *tired* I am of the word? It's like it's the
only British insult out there, which I *know* can't be true. And
I'm not sure it really even applies to Snape. He's many things, but
stupid or foolish (the definition I found) is not one of them. It's
weird what fandom will glomp onto.
Amiable Dorsai:
Well, there's "berk", of course, A bit sexist, perhaps, though I've
heard it used as a term of almost affectionate contempt, "Greasy
berk"?... I dunno, just seems wrong, somehow.
"Tosser" at least implies a certain human quality, but it's just a bad
image for me. "Greasy tosser" gives him credit for a certain
practicality, I suppose. He does seem a quite practical sort, when
he's not raving.
"Nosey-parker": accurate, in the same sense that it would be accurate
to say that New Orleans had a bit of a plumbing problem.
"Buggering manky arse" is somewhere in the right vicinity. Add
"greasy", and we're once again giving him credit for practicality.
Something of a mouthful, though.
I dunno, "greasy git" is pithy, alliterative, and, when applied to
Snape, understated. Hard to beat, don't you think?
Amiable Dorsai
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive