Horcrux problem

[Lyn]

No: HPFGUIDX 144597

charon_death_ngfh <charondeathngfh at ntlworld.com> wrote:
> Dumbledore had already said that when a horcrux is created 
> it leaves a mark.  I suppose Harry's scar could simply be 
> just that a scar left as a visible reminder of what happened 
> to his parents but what if it is more than that? 
>
<snip>
>
> <snip> Originally LV was going to use something from the house 
> as his final horcrux but this backfired somehow and Harry 
> became the horcrux.  It is the only explanation as to how Harry 
> shares talents of LV's, that could only happen if Harry had 
> somehow absorbed some of LV's soul.


I understand how you could think it is the only explanation to 
Harry sharing powers of Voldy's, but we can't assume anything 
with JKR. Don't you think it's possible that Voldy did in fact 
perform the AK curse onto Harry, rebounded onto LV, and as it 
was rebounding somehow powers were transfered to Harry instead 
of killing him as the curse intended? 

  It is a good argument when you mention DD saying a horcrux 
has a mark on it, but it is possible that it is a coincidence 
and JKR gave us readers that bit of info because she wanted us 
to falsely believe Harry is a Horcrux. I dunno...
   
  -Lyn