Triple binding between Harry and Voldemort?

h2so3f h2so3f at yahoo.com
Thu Dec 15 13:51:29 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144783

> Jen wrote: 
>" ... CH3ed brought up the idea the potion produced a less-
> than-human body in #142534 but it didn't occur to me Dumbledore's 
> gleam might be related to flaws other than Harry's blood." 

bboyminn wrote:
"I don't necessarily think it was 'other than Harry's blood'. In that
moment, Dumbledore saw the flaw in using Harry's blood, but I think
what else he saw was re-enforce his general opinion of 
Voldemort."<snip>


CH3ed:
I actually saw it as DD seeing the flaw in that it was Wormtail (who 
owes Harry his life) who injured Harry to collect the blood for LV, 
so that "betrayal" might render the potion (and the body resulting 
from it) less than optimal. But I had completely overlooked the 
unwillingness of Wormtail himself in giving up his flesh. That's a 
good catch!! So there likely are 2 flaws in the making of the 
resurrection potion. 

CH3ed finds bboyminn's analysis of LV's shortsightedness so thorough 
he has nothing to add.  :O)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive