Forgiving Snape was FF: Re: Who does Snape really hate?

Miles miles at martinbraeutigam.de
Thu Dec 15 15:07:12 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144788

> Miles:
> Harry himself is much more responsible for Sirius' death, and he
> projects
> his own guilt onto Snape. But we should not take Harry's PoV as
> granted.

> Sherry
> What I have to disagree with is the idea that Harry is responsible for
> Sirius' death.  i argue this point vehemently, every time it comes up
> here.
> Bella, the death eaters, Voldemort, they are responsible.

Miles:
I did not make my point clear enough.
No, I don't think Harry is to be blamed for Sirius' death. But when HE
blames SNAPE for it, then we should consider, that his own responsibility -
mainly to forget about the mirror - is much more important than Snape's.
That is, if he points at Snape blaming him, four of his fingers point at
himself.

Miles





More information about the HPforGrownups archive