R.A.B. & Missing Horcrux/DEs saying Voldemort

susanbones2003 rdas at facstaff.wisc.edu
Mon Dec 19 00:07:15 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144956

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "loco_noco03" 
<loco_noco03 at y...> wrote:
>
> Forgive me if I repeat something, I'm a newbie.  But I wanted to 
> respond to/clear up this confusion.
> 
> Cathy D writes:
> there are lots
> of people who call Voldemort *The Dark Lord*. I wish I had taken 
the 
> time to
> list them all. One of which, though, is Ginny Weasley in her 
> Valentine to
> Harry.
> 
> Loco writes:
> If you are refering to the Valentine she gave Harry in CoS, then 
> wouldn't it make sense for her to call him the Dark Lord because 
she 
> was possessed/being controlled by him at the time.  Also, the only 
> other "good" person I recall refering to LV as The Dark Lord is SS 
in 
> the HBP.  Now this could be for one of a few reasons.  Either SS 
is 
> in fact a DE (which I do not believe) or this is part of his cover 
> which he had to maintain seeing as Draco is in the class.  I could 
> easily see Jo writing that in as well to give the reader 
superficial 
> reason to believe he is actually a DE and stray away from second 
> guessing this theory.
> 
> If you have any references of anyone else other than DEs refering 
to 
> LV as the dark lord please tell me so I can confirm/reject this 
> theory.
>
This is a somewhat meta-related fact, but it was in GOF, at the end, 
when Barty Crouch Jr. began to reveal himself to Harry and used the 
term "Dark Lord" that I realized how terribly wrong something was 
going. It was done in such a way as to be almost a throwaway thing, 
in passing. She is very good at flooding a scene with actions and 
facts and dialogue so that a telling clue can be lost in the mix. I 
realize that the whole thing was resolved in just a few pages, but 
she built up to the resolution in a very skillfully dramatic fashion 
so that just as Harry is having that "OH NO!" moment of horror, we 
were as well.
Jen D








More information about the HPforGrownups archive