Umbridge a DE? (was: Wizard Logic)

Corey Overton coverton at netscape.com
Tue Dec 20 06:21:18 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 145037

pippin_999 wrote:
> > Many wizards might reach the same conclusions as Harry, but then, 
> > as we all know, a lot of wizards haven't an ounce of logic.

Bart:
> Especially in the Ministry. I mean, Umbridge ADMITTED that she
> had sent the dementors after Harry; she's guilty of a bunch of 
> crimes, topped with attempted murder, and she's still at the 
> Ministry. I HOPE that it's more than incredible incompetence on the 
> part of the Ministry (maybe it's an important clue), but I doubt it.


Hi, its Corey.  Does anyone think Umbridge just might be a death eater? I know she doesn't have the Mark but maybe Voldemort didn't put it on her to throw people off. Just a thought. 

Your fellow member, 
Corey






More information about the HPforGrownups archive