Umbridge a DE?.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 145059

"va32h" <va32h at c...> wrote:

> Her purpose is to show us, as Sirius told
> Harry, that the world isn't divided into
> good guys and Death Eaters.

I agree.

> Umbridge is sadistic, vile, and cruel,
> but no Death Eater. 

I agree.

> this theme would be played out better if JKR 
> showed us a friendly and cheerful Death Eater
> for comparison.

I disagree. All Death Eaters are evil, but not all evil people are
Death Eaters.

Eggplant