Heroes and Not (WAS: Who killed Dumbledore?)

[Miles]

No: HPFGUIDX 145175

> Sherry
> i suppose that depends on what you believe happened on the Tower.  i
> happen
> to believe that Snape, for his own reasons, whatever they are,
> murdered
> Dumbledore.  i don't believe it was a plan between him and DD.  i
> think he
> should have died rather than fulfill the UV, if he was loyal to
> Dumbledore.

Miles:
Just hold this point. What would have happened after this? Dumbledore was
weak and wandless. Snape had no chance fighting four DEs alone, so
Dumbledore would have been killed anyway. After Dumbledore's death Harry
would have been able to move again. Would he? Possibly, and then?

What you demand of Snape is absolutely senseless self sacrifice. If he acted
that way, the 6th book most probably would be the last one.

Miles