Dumbledore Wrong?

[susanbones2003]

No: HPFGUIDX 145178

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "graverobber23" 
<graverobber23 at y...> wrote:
>> 
> graverobber: 
> 
> Voldemort didn't die when he cursed Harry Potter. He became a 
> spirit as we saw in Sorcerer's Stone. So therefore, LV's horcrux 
> did not die. So there are actually 5 horcruxes still out there. 
> 1) Hufflepuff's cup, 2)Something of Griffindor's, 3) Slitherin's 
> Locket, 4) Nagini, and 5) LV himself. (HBP)
> 
> Now the true question is.... What is the thing from Godric 
> Griffindor? My thoughts are on Godric Griffindor's sword.

Jen D here,
Harry used that sword in COS. Wouldn't there have been some indication 
if it had been something as dark and dangerous as a horcrux? Are 
horcruxes neutral? The diary certainly seemed to have the power to do 
evil, given the right circumstances.
Just a question.
Jen D
>