Who told Umbridge leading to dark thoughts about Flitwick

saraquel_omphale saraquel_omphale at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 23 08:58:15 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 145256

Saraquel:
Thanks to Krysta, Taylor and Geoff, and welcome to the list Krysta 
and Taylor. No doubt, if I'd waited to post until after I'd finished 
my re-read, I'd have answered my own question!

> Krystyna:
> As JKR have said somewhere (interview? her website?), Flitwick has 
> some goblin blood in him, therefore seems unlikely as an ally with 
> pure-blood, human-obsessed Umbridge. Not to mention that we see 
him 
> on many occasions being quite unhelpful towards Umbridge.

I quite agree about Flitwick hating Umbridge, but going down the 
line of Flitwick being ESE, even if he hated Umbridge, he could have 
used her to try anstop the DA from going ahead, so I don't think 
that being against Umbridge equals DDM per se.  I still have a 
question mark as to why Snape took him out in HBP - it would 
indicate an ESE!Snape, but to me there is too much other evidence 
for things to be that straightforward - ho hum.


Saraquel
Good cricketing weather here, Geoff!







More information about the HPforGrownups archive