Dumbledore Wrong? - The Sword.

[scamjunk22]

No: HPFGUIDX 145279

> bboyminn:
> We have narrowed this discussion to a Gryffindor object, but 
> the truth is, it could be a Gryffindor OR RAVENCLAW object, and
> I personally think it is more likely to be a Ravenclaw object. 
> My speculation, either the Wand on the cushion in the Window of 
> Ollivanders or the tiara the Harry used to mark the location of
> his Potions Book. 
> 
> <snip> I don't necessarily see the Gryffindor Sword as being 
> available to enchant into a Horcrux. I think it magically 
> appeared from obscurity, called by the Sorting Hat to come to 
> Harry's aid. 
> 
> So, I was trying to answer the question in the context it was
> presented, but truthfully, I don't think the Sword is a Horcrux.


Exactly ... it could be a Ravenclaw object... couldn't LV have 
said, "ok, let me lay my hands on a Ravenclaw object and then try 
for the Gryffindor object" ?? We DON'T know where he was after he 
left B&B and before he came back seeking employment at Hogwarts. 
So he would definitely have made three horcruxes in that time ... 
na? When he disappeared, he had in his possession the locket and 
the cup + he might have come across another object in B&B itself 
.... the cursed necklace!!! It could have been Ravenclaw's .. na? 
Why are we forgetting that? It has been mentioned twice already 
in the series with the last mention of it being sent to SNAPE! 
What (other than the fact that some of us *hope* that he is a 
DDM!!!) can have stopped him from returning it to LV .... (me 
assuming that Snapey knows about the Horcruxes)..????? 

Btw, if anybody has tried to speculate this before ---- where can 
the other horcruxes be? Nagini is with his all the time. The 
locket may be in Grimmauld Place for all we know ..... the cup?? 
Where could it be? If HP has to find it, it should have easy 
access ... na?

JMO,

Scam, who is going sick with speculation ... somebody please 
forward my plea for an early release of book 7 to JKR.