Dumbledore and hating children for their parents sins. WAS: TBAY; Definitely NOT

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 145318

Alla:
> > Do you think that DD!M Snape is loyal to the Light or loyal only
to
> > Dumbledore? Even if he is loyal to Dumbledore only, it still IMO
> > would mean that he at least partially loyal to what Dumbledore
> > preaches and practices and that is not IMO hating children for
the
> > sins of their parents real or imaginery.
>
> Pippin:
> Does Dumbledore ever say that? Does he ever even say that Snape
> shouldn't hate Harry? Nobody seems willing to say that, not even
> Sirius or Lupin, and given what we saw in the Pensieve, it's
> understandable, IMO.
>
> DD says he thought that Snape could overcome his feelings about
> Harry's father, but he *never* says that he blames Snape for not
> doing so.

Alla:

What I meant is that Dumbledore IMO acts that way - namely not
blaming children for the sins of their fathers and if Snape is loyal
to him, I would think he should have at least try to act the similar
way.

Lucius Malfoy did everything possible in CoS IMO to throw Dumbledore
out of school and that happened IMO when Dumbledore wanted and was
needed in Hogwarts. That is a fact, IMO. Lucius Malfoy slipped the
Diary to the daughter of the trusted member of the Order, something
which Dumbledore IMO would not like at all.

It sure did not look to me in HBP that Dumbledore acted as if he
hold Draco in any way responsible for Lucius deeds and Dumbledore
even offered to hide Lucius too.

Hmmm, how about Snape taking a page out of Dumbledore's book and
follow his examples? Because IMO throwing Dumbledore out of school
was personal offense to Dumbledore.

JMO,

Alla