Ton-tongue Dudley, Twins
Corey Overton
coverton at netscape.com
Sat Dec 24 09:36:54 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 145368
Betsy Hp:
> You brought up the ton-tongue incident, and I think there *is*
> a lasting effect there. <snip> There is a tension between
> wizards and muggles. The Dursleys hate wizards, think they're
> untrustworthy and dangerous. The twins proved their fears
> beautifully.
Bruce:
> Did they force the toffee down his throat? <snip> Dudley
> picked it up and ate it of his own free will and accord. <snip>
> He has nobody to thank for what happened but his own gluttonous
> self. <snip>
Corey:
Bruce is right in my opinion, I have to disagree with Betsy. The
twins aren't evil. If I remember after the incident in question
Arther asks the twins why he gave it to the muggle and they said
"we didn't give it to him cause he's a muggle; no, we gave it to
him cause he's a great bullying git, isn't he Harry?" So even how
I agree with Bruce now that I write this I can see both sides of
the debate.
Corey
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive