The Second Horcrux Thief

kchuplis kchuplis at alltel.net
Thu Dec 29 15:15:23 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 145558

Neuman wrote:

> The first Horcrux thief is R.A.B. The second Horcrux thief is none
> other then Lily Potter! It's such a simple solution that I'm amazed
> that no one thought of it before. Think about it:
<go UPTHREAD to read the reasons>

kchuplis:
Well, it does give a plot reason to go back to Cedric's Hollow. We 
know Harry is going to go there in Book 7 and right now, there is no 
plot motivation, just character motivation and we all know she is not 
going to be able to dwell on "B" lines much. NOt a bad idea. Might be 
helpful too, if we find others had figured out the horcrux thing and 
were attempting to find them before the big blow up. Then RAB and 
Lily get killed. Heck, half the aurors got killed, which put a halt 
to it. Hmmm. Interesting theory anyway.

kchuplis












More information about the HPforGrownups archive