The Second Horcrux Thief(and Longbottom)

[chewbacca98407]

No: HPFGUIDX 145579


> Neuman:
> > The first Horcrux thief is R.A.B. The second Horcrux thief is 
none other then Lily Potter! >
>   
> kchuplis:
> <<Might be helpful too, if we find others had figured out the 
horcrux thing and were attempting to find them before the big blow 
up. Then RAB and Lily get killed.>>
>    
>   Peg:
>   It would make sense, too, for Regulus to share the information 
about the hurcruxes with the Potters.  <snip>


Chewie now: 
Let's not forget the Longbottom affair.  Dumbledore 
tells Harry that they were tortured by Bella and co. for information 
on the whereabouts of Lord V right.....stay with me.....if Lilly 
stole a horcrux( as postulated above) then couldn't the Longbottoms 
have one also?  Bellatrix could have been more than mad that the 
Longbottoms were concealing info. on her master's location, she 
could have 
believed they stole a horcrux.  Again, as stated by Neuman, 
they may or may not even have known the significance of what they 
had taken.  We only have conjecture, but if one is possible so is 
the second.  It would also tend to add more weight to that whole 
torture scene.  I have believed (upon re-reading) that ever since 
the Spinner's End slip when Bella is talking of LV entrusting her 
with "his most prescious" that this "precious" was a horcrux.  I 
think she lost track of the one he gave to her to keep safe.  It may 
or may not have been the locket, but if it was, and RAB is 
Regulus...I could go on and on. IMHO that torture scene with the 
Longbottoms was always a little over the top, but this 
would make more sense to me.  Oh my...J.K. will have to take us to 
Nevile's house next...eeekkk...gran scares me!

Chewie