[HPforGrownups] Re: Real child abuse/ Mcgonagall

[Jazmyn Concolor]

No: HPFGUIDX 145589



dumbledore11214 wrote:

> Alla:
>
>I won't argue with you about whether Snape is a child abuser or not, 
>I've done plenty of arguing on this topic and suspect that I will do 
>plenty more in the future, I just want to object to "term being 
>thrown around carelessly". Please believe me, I do not throw around 
>the words "child abuse" carelessly, I certainly thought a lot before 
>I determined for myself that Snape is a child abuser and of course I 
>make the distinctions between cases you described and what Snape 
>does. The cases you describe are the cases of physical abuse IMO 
>Snape is an emotional abuser with the strong potential to be the 
>physical one as shows IMO what he did to Harry after Pensieve trip.
>
>
>  
>
If someone had gone into my most private thoughts, I would have been a 
lot more violent then Snape.  What Harry did was unforgivable, 
carelessly diving into the private thoughts of not only another person, 
but a teacher and a member of the Order of the Phoenix.  The pensieve 
was in use to keep Harry away from those memories and he knew it and 
violated the pensieve anyways.  Secrets he could have picked up from 
this in the wrong memory might have made him a terrible danger to the 
cause.  He is a CHILD and should not be just peeking at the private 
thoughts and memories of a spy for the Order!!!!   Snape was in fact a 
lot more restrained then most people in his position would be.  I would 
likely have throttled the little git.   How does one handle a nosey, 
egotistical brat who can't keep out of the 'Top Secret files'?? 

Harry is a loose canon who doesn't care about the consequences of his 
actions, who leads his friends onto danger, his monstrous ego believing 
he can defeat Voldemort as nothing more then a kid.   Harry should be 
locked up before he gets anymore people killed or worse.  He is already 
responsible for leading his godfather to his death. 

Jazmyn