Support for the ESE Lupin theory! NOT - howabout ESE!Snape?

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 123884


-
> Charme:
 Plus Snape overrode 
> what Lupin tried to say after that lovely, apparently Seer-like
explanation 
> Snape gave. I mean, the last time we saw Lupin take the potion,
Harry was in 
> attendance and Snape *brought* it to Lupin's office for him to take.
Uhm and 
> how did Lupin blow off Snape's announcement anyway? He said 1 word:
Severus. 
> (Don't shoot the messenger - that's what the canon states.) Seems to
me that 
> maybe someone should be trying to figure out how Snape knew in
advance of 
> bringing Lupin his potion that Lupin'd fogotten to take it......
> 
> Charme

Finwitch:

Right. Snape was LATE. Lupin took a secondary measure, and left for
the safety-place that had been there when Lupin was a student, leaving
the map behind -- for Severus to bring it *there*! AND, aside from the
safety place, Lupin knew, now, that Padfoot was innocent and
definately would keep him from harming anyone if it came to that.

Uck. Snape's blaming Lupin for *his own* mistake! Snape's the one
brewing it (Lupin doesn't know how) As, I believe, he's been accusing
Sirius of the event during their teen-years long ago... And Lupin
knows that. 'Ah, that trick' - the SAME trick Severus used again.
Snape's trick of saying things to make others look bad, while being -
in their careful wording, - true enough to even the Legilimens...

And don't forget, the RAT did much the same thing - frame others and
act innocent!

Both of them bear the Dark Mark, and both of them are as good at
acting innocent as Barty Crouch Jr.

Dumbledore can keep repeating his 'I trust Severus Snape' mantra all
he likes, but I won't be trusting that Dark-Mark bearer. No way.

Finwitch