TT altering DD's memory. Ouch again!

northsouth17 northsouth17 at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 8 12:25:57 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 124192




> Sandra:
> > I'd say he'd have a right headache. He'd remember WHAT, exactly?
> > 
> > To spell it out: immediately after advising H&H to turn back 
time, 
> he leaves 
> > the hospital wing. As far as he's concerned, he meets them again 
> outside the 
> > door and apparently has no idea why he's meeting them again - yet 
> he's 
> > prepared not to question what they've been up to.
<snip>

> Geoff:
> <ducks and looks nervously over shoulder> If I might risk 
> excommunication and refer to the "medium that dare not speak it's 
> name", this is almost suggested at the end of HP:POA when Harry and 
> Hermione return to the hospital wing and say to Dumbledore "We've 
> done it" - or words to that effect and Dumbledore replies "Done 
what?"
> <snip>

DD knows he sent H&H back though. When they show up outside the door, 
he knows that 3 hours have passed for them from a moment ago when he 
saw them. He knows, or at least asusmes, that since they're alive and 
well, they acted according to the plan that he hinted at and that 
Sirius has escaped with Buckbeak. It annoys me that he was so cryptic 
though. Couldn't he have saved some, uh, more time and just 
said "Rescue Buckbeak, fly to the windows, rescue Sirius?" 

Northsouth










More information about the HPforGrownups archive