*MY* confusion-Time Turner: Could vs Would

[delwynmarch]

No: HPFGUIDX 124213


Steve/bboyminn wrote:
"IF Sirius has already been saved, THEN all motivation and need to
help him is lost. Again, why fix something that isn't broken? Why
would you want to save someone who doesn't need saving?"

Del replies:
:-)
Well, we know that *something* would happen that would make them
realise that they must Time-Turn because... they *have* Time-Turned!

History can't be changed. History happened the way it did because
Harry and Hermione Time-Turned. So no matter what, they *will*
Time-Turn. Something, anything, will lead them to the conclusion that
they must Time-Turn.

And in fact, this is *exactly* what happened in PoA. Harry and
Hermione Time-Turned, and by the end of their Time-Turning DD realised
that their current version must Time-Turn, as you described.

It would have happened just the same if they had Time-Turned a couple
of hours later.

What do you think?

Del