Don't be seen? / Re: *MY* confusion about the Time Turner - small point on rules

kgpopp kgpopp at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 8 22:59:08 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 124227


 
> Del:
> Even worse : Harry may have survived because he broke the main rule 
> of Time-Turning : "Don't be seen". That Harry is something special 
> indeed :-) On his first use of a TT, he demonstrates that the 
> rule "Don't be seen" can actually be counter-productive :-D !


Kristen responds:

I don't think there is a rule that you should not be seen.  I think 
the rule is that wizards are not suppose to time travel because they 
don't want them to change the course of events. i.e. Because H&H used 
the Time Turner, Buckbeak lives but per the MOM Buckbeak was not 
suppose to live.  (I tried to word that so that I did not re-start 
the debate on if H&H did change things).

So the do not be seen thing is really just common sense, or 
Hermione's own rule so that they don't get caught.   













More information about the HPforGrownups archive