Dumbledore the incompetent councilor

[horridporrid03]

No: HPFGUIDX 124499


>>Eggplant: 
>I'm sure Serious Black had his faults, but for Dumbledore to 
enumerate every one of them to Harry...<

Betsy:
Erm... huh?  You'll have to quote canon for me here Eggplant.  I just 
reread that scene and there's no part where Dumbledore enumerate's 
every one of Sirius's faults to Harry.  He did say that Sirius was 
brave and clever.  Do you consider those faults?  Is that what you're 
talking about?

>>Eggplant:
>...it would certainly make me want to smack Dumbledore right in his 
smug little face.<

Betsy:
Smug?  Again, you've lost me.  When, exactly, did Dumbledore express 
smugness?

Betsy