mixed marriages
stbjohn2
stbjohn2 at yahoo.com
Mon Feb 14 21:08:51 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 124547
Sandy wrote: >
> > In CoS, Ron says, "most wizards are half bloods these days
anyway.
> > If we hadn't married muggles, we'd've died out." While one of
Ron's
> > functions is to give us insight into the opinions of ordinary
> > wizards, I wonder if Ron is somewhat overstating the case. Or is
he
> > talking about some vague time in the past, when wizards had
almost
> > died out and had to marry muggles; or more recently, say his
> > grandparent's generation, in the pre-rise-of-Voldy days (perhaps
> > that's what gave Tom Riddle his idea on how to ride the wave of
> > purebloodism to power).
> >
> > It's true that we have very little information on marriage in the
> WW
> > in general, and are as clueless as Harry about the wizard or
muggle
> > heritage of most of his classmates, but as far as I know, there
> are
> > only three instances of muggle/wizard unions in canon, and one of
> > those comes not from the books, but JKR's website.
> >
> > The three mixed marriages that we know about are Tom Riddle's
> mother
> > (witch) to Tom Riddle Sr. (muggle); Seamus Finnegan's mother
> (witch)
> > and father (muggle), and Dean Thomas mother (muggle) and father
> > (wizard) -- the last from JKR's website. >snip
>
Imamommy replied:
>
> I think we also have to take into account that the pureblood
> aristocracy does not view muggleborn wizards and witches (ie Tonks'
> father or Hermione) as counting as pureblood. Ron may be
including
> them when he says this.
>
Sandy says
Possibly, but Ron specifically says "muggles" not "muggles, half-
bloods and muggleborns".
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive