Does Dumbledore love Harry?
Bethany
bethanymil79 at yahoo.com
Thu Feb 17 14:20:31 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 124802
Lupinlore:
snip
> Another way to put it is: What would DD give up for Harry? Would
> he give up his life? Would he give up the future of the WW (as he
> implies he was in effect doing, in my opinion)? Would he give up
> another student? Would he give up the Order? Would he give up
> Hogwarts?
I think Dumbledore most definitely loves Harry far above the rest of
the students... in a grandfather/father sort of way. I think so
many times that Harry is going to end up staying with Dumbledore in
the end should he survive. (Which I would love.)
As far as what Dumbledore would give up for Harry... that's kind of
tricky. I mean, to what extent do we sacrifice for the greater
good? Who wants to think about giving up their child to save the
world? It's almost a Christ comparison... comparing Dumbledore to
God who gave up his son Jesus (Harry) to save the human race. Also,
what does Harry bring to the table? We don't know exactly yet. If
in fact he is the one to save the WW, then I'm sure Dumbledore would
sacrifice whatever to get Harry to the point he needs to get to -
meaning other individual lives. At that point however, if it took
Harry's life to save the rest of the WW I think Dumbledore would
have to let him go no matter how much he hated it.
I don't think that sacrifice and love can be compared though. God
loved Jesus far more than we can comprehend, but He let Him die to
save the world... I think Dumbledore would have to do the same.
(Hope I'm not stretching too far here.)
-Bethany
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive